gemini+submit:// (was Re: Uploading Gemini content)

[case]

On June 13, 2020 2:56:35 PM MDT, solderpunk <solderpunk at SDF.ORG> wrote:
>A couple of thoughts on this new line of discussion:
>

>3. Dear God, when/where/how does it stop?!  This was supposed to be a
>simple, humble, protocol of limited scope!

To me, this is key and exactly where the web went off the rails. If this is embraced by the community it becomes a defacto standard; clients that do not support it will be considered less. This is what happened to mosaic and Netscape.

>
>6. Does anybody else feel like we are just instinctively
>re-implementing
>the familiar history of the web without much caution or critical
>thought?

Yes!


Why does this have to be a part of or associated with gemini at all? Why not build a separate protocol and client and build a community of authors around it?

In my mind gemini is a passive reader's tool. It gets all of the noise out of the way, advertising, comments, likes, social media distractions, incentives to grow audiences etc...

How about a protocol extension that says user input MUST NOT be persisted by servers?

Cheers,
Case


-- Email domain proudly hosted at https://migadu.com