a space case for transparent gemtext compression

Stephane Bortzmeyer stephane at sources.org
Sat Jun 19 09:59:14 BST 2021
On Sat, Jun 19, 2021 at 02:15:45AM -0500,
 Christian Seibold <krixano@mailbox.org> wrote 
 a message of 3 lines which said:

> If you're using zips, Lagrange doesn't take 4 user actions, it takes
> 1. If other browsers don't have this functionality, then tell
> them. Browsers should implement this, not the protocol. It's that's
> simple.

If I understand correctly your proposal, you suggest to change,
neither the protocol nor the gemtext format, but to push browser
authors to recognize text/gemini+gzip and act accordingly.

In that case, I see two issues:

* how the end user of a browser without compression support will know
in advance if the file is compressed or not? From the file extension?
It is not always present.

=> ilovecompression.gmiz I cannot read it
=> plain.gmi I can read it

* today, every browser can read every Gemini file. Your proposal
seems to imply that some users will now see only a part of the
Geminispace, the uncompressed one. This is the same problem we have
when trying to use the Web with lynx or dillo: we can see only a part
of it.



Archive home | About this archive